Beware Unauthorized Occupants!

Taking in a roommate or a long-term guest seems innocuous enough. Maybe it’s a means to pay the rent or a goodwill gesture to a friend or family member. But the presence of unauthorized occupants may be a breach of the lease or rental agreement so it’s always smart to read what it allows and then secure permission from the landlord if necessary. Lets look at a couple of situations that may get the unwitting tenant into some trouble. Read More Beware Unauthorized Occupants!

Evicted After 29 Years at 458 South Roxbury Drive

David Berke move-out day at 458 South RoxburyWhat remained today after resident David Berke cleared out of his place.

His landlord, Stephen Copen, served David and his his two sons with a 60-day, no-just-cause notice to evict after 29 years in his apartment at 458 South Roxbury Drive. The family’s final pack-up culminated in a harried garage sale, filled-up refuse bins and an uprooted garden. David’s priority now is simply to stay housed so his two kids can finish high school. The family’s final exit from Beverly Hills can’t come too soon for him.

Last year, Copen also threw out David’s upstairs neighbor for no cause. She had been there for 30 years. Her eviction came within a year or so after Copen bought the building, adding it to at least six other properties owned with his wife, Naghmeh Makhani. Copen is a longtime Beverly Hills rental property owner but these folks don’t even call our town home.

David’s eviction put me in mind of a remark he made to City Council exactly a year ago. There were some changes to the rent stabilization law and Copen wasn’t happy. “You haven’t discussed whether people living in a two bedroom apartment across from Roxbury park with a view of the clubhouse should maybe economize,” he told the councilmembers, before grousing further about how he “subsidized” his tenants. If you are a Copen tenant the video is worth a watch. Have you a story to share about the Copens? Something concerning no-cause evictions, sham tenants, or substandard property maintenance, perhaps? I’m all ears.

Update: with 29-year tenant David Berke out, Copen could move in a tenant for the briefest of tenures and then move that tenant out and then raise the rent to market. That’s what we’re told anyway. And that’s what he evidently did after he kicked-out David’s 30-year upstairs neighbor.

Copen evidently made few or no upgrades to the property exterior (or unit exterior) while his longtime tenants resided there. But once David was out it was a different story: time for curb appeal! A refresh of the exterior (below) and an interior renovation (without permits) repositions the property for that next lucky Copen tenant!

Oh what a spruce-up after 30 years of neglect will do for curb appeal! Gone is the fence and in its place lovely flowers. All primped for the next lucky Copen tenant!

Update on Statewide Efforts to Protect Tenants

Surveys show that nearly one-third of us live paycheck-to-paycheck. Some of us pay over half of our household income in rent. Many tenants have little savings. And Beverly Hills allow no-just-cause eviction, which can mean an unexpected pack-up and moving expenses we can ill-afford. Because the most effective way to prevent homelessness is to ensure that people stay housed, several efforts are underway to address the challenges faced by precariously-housed tenants in California. Read More Update on Statewide Efforts to Protect Tenants

Will Greater Protections for Tenants Make the November Ballot?

A petition making the rounds of Beverly Hills multifamily areas seeks to put an initiative on the November. The initiative, dryly titled ‘Expands Local Governments’ Authority To Enact Rent Control On Residential Property,’ would repeal a state law called Costa Hawkins Rental Housing Act. That law since 1995 has greatly limited the reach of local governments that would extend rent control protections to tenants. Should it qualify, I hope this initiative finds support among those who rent because it is the best opportunity we have to expand tenant protections both statewide and in Beverly Hills. Read More Will Greater Protections for Tenants Make the November Ballot?

Limits on Unit Occupancy: It’s Complicated!

Recently an apartment adjacent to mine leased quite quickly. The new tenants, nice guys all, introduced themselves. Three adult men seemed a tight fit for a one-bedroom apartment smaller than 500 square feet. It raised two questions. Why would three men rent that apartment? How many people can a landlord pack into a small place? The answer is not as straightforward as one might think. I did a little digging! Read More Limits on Unit Occupancy: It’s Complicated!

Chapter 5 Rent Stabilization: 39 Years Young Today!

Thirty-nine years ago today, on March 27, 1979, the City of Beverly Hills enacted a “temporary system of stabilization and control of apartment rent levels.” The introduction to the Municipal Code of Chapter 5 Rent Stabilization that year was an effort to draw a line under the problem of excessive rent increases and destabilizing turnover in rental housing. Just as City Council recently observed when it adopted the original urgency ordinance last January, the cost of rental housing was moving beyond reach of residents and threatening the stability of households that rent. Then and now renters comprise more than half of all households in the city. But often protections come too little and too late. But Chapter 5 delivered for tenants. Read More Chapter 5 Rent Stabilization: 39 Years Young Today!

Pets in the Unit: Know Your Rights!

Incidents involving disruptive animals in airplanes have garnered much attention recently because farm animals like pigs and peacocks don’t seem a good fit for a tight cabin. Yet they may fly as ‘emotional support’ animals under federal rules. Tenants can claim the same accommodation and may use it to keep a landlord from turning away a pet. But is that advisable? Let’s take a closer look at pets in apartments and review the tenant’s options. Read More Pets in the Unit: Know Your Rights!

Rent Stabilization Update: A Long Time Coming

It has been a while since residents received an update from City Hall about rent stabilization. The rental unit registry was completed in January and other aspects of program implementation have continued, yet we’ve heard nothing about either. The tenant workshops came and went nine months ago, and though City Council approved the hiring of a rent stabilization program director in September, no one has been hired for the position. This very important housing program seems not to be a priority for City Hall. Read More Rent Stabilization Update: A Long Time Coming

Mold in the Unit: It’s Complicated!

Landlords and tenants tend to get anxious when hearing the term ‘mold.’ But it’s important to remember that while mold is a moisture problem, the presence of moisture isn’t necessarily a mold problem. That is, humidity creates conditions for mold to grow but toxic mold should not prevail in our relatively dry climate unless it is left unaddressed. Mold is “complicated,” as they say, and so is getting help if you suspect mold is present in your apartment. Read More Mold in the Unit: It’s Complicated!

Rent Stabilization Update: What’s Next

Months have passed without a single word from Beverly Hills officials about rent stabilization reform. No press release, newspaper ad, or website update keeps us informed about the process even though the current policy is only temporary and change will come. Officials let weeks go by without a reply when asked. Even a public records request can be met with an incomplete response. And don’t get me started about the programs that must be managed better in order to properly serve tenants. Read More Rent Stabilization Update: What’s Next

Republican Tax Cuts: Bad News for Tenants!

What do Republican tax cuts mean for those who rent housing? A recent opinion piece in the NY Post suggests some good news: ‘New tax law is a huge win for renters’ reads the headline. But don’t be fooled. The American Apartment Owners Association calls ‘tax reform’ a gift to landlords. Indeed headlines like ‘GOP Tax Bill Rewards Real Estate’ and ‘GOP Tax Plan Holds Benefits for Landlords’ suggest the actual beneficiaries of so-called reform. With that ‘huge win for renters’ canard out of the way, let’s have a look at the real gifts bestowed by the Republican Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. There are many! Read More Republican Tax Cuts: Bad News for Tenants!

Tenants Seeking Legal Services: The Challenge Continues!

Beverly Hills offers few protections to the 8,600 households that rent. Unlike rent-stabilized cities that prohibit no-just-cause evictions or mandate minimum habitability standards, Beverly Hills simply falls back on the state’s civil code. That means tenants are on our own to defend our housing rights in court; we can’t depend on the city to step up. It is crucial that tenants get the most we can out of the city-funded housing rights legal services program. Read More Tenants Seeking Legal Services: The Challenge Continues!

Registration Lagging, City Council Imposes a New Penalty

Beverly Hills City Council wrapped up the year with two final administrative actions. In November the city hired a consultant to conduct an economic analysis; and on December 19th City Council passed an ordinance to impose a penalty on landlords that fail to register their property: no rent increase until the property is registered in the rental unit registry. Why the new penalty? One-in-five properties still are not registered. Read More Registration Lagging, City Council Imposes a New Penalty

When Landlords Put Profit Before Maintenance


200 South Reeves exterior dilapidationBeverly Hills residents take well-kept properties for granted. High-and-rising values generate resources for maintenance and, in turn, maintenance keeps property values up. But maintenance is not part of the business model for some owners of residential rental property. Instead their priority is cash flow. But scrimping on maintenance not only affects tenants; it also augurs an overall decline in the city’s rental housing stock. Read More When Landlords Put Profit Before Maintenance

This Thanksgiving I’m Thankful for a Decent Property Manager

One of the things I’m thankful for is the quiet enjoyment of my apartment with friends and family on Thanksgiving. Quiet enjoyment is my right as a tenant (the court has ruled) and I am thankful that my property management company conducts business professionally to allow it. That includes responding to problems relatively quickly – something that every tenant should be able to take that for granted. Read More This Thanksgiving I’m Thankful for a Decent Property Manager

Rent Stabilization: Where are We Now? [Updated]

Update: Tenants and landlords looking forward to a final rent stabilization policy for Beverly Hills will have to wait a while longer. On November 21st City Council handed over to a national consulting firm, HR&A Advisors, the task of rent stabilization analysis. The consultant will undertake data collection, analysis, and even convene additional facilitated dialogues, culminating in a process that may unfold over the next 18-22 weeks. That extends the timeline for the rent stabilization discussion to nearly to years between the time that Council issued an urgency ordinance last January and the conclusion of the policy process by the new year. Read More Rent Stabilization: Where are We Now? [Updated]

This Landlord Wants OUR Tenant-City Communications

During the the facilitated dialogues this summer, Beverly Hills landlords sat across the table from our tenants committee and opposed, in every way they could muster, the registry of rental units at the heart of the city’s rent stabilization program. It is a means to hold landlords accountable, of course, and that’s why they have embraced a scorched-earth campaign (and even a lawsuit) to pressure City Council to stop it. At the same time, a landlord has sought from the city all tenant complaints to code enforcement, including communications about unit conditions and rent increases. How do we know? I filed my own public records request on the landlord. Is potential tenant intimidation a step too far? Read More This Landlord Wants OUR Tenant-City Communications

Tax-Cut Winners: Landlords! (Updated)

Last week much attention was focused on winners and losers. Republicans in the House of Representatives narrowly passed a budget resolution (‘blueprint’ it was called) as a step toward tax cuts. While sold as a middle-class cut, analysts say that the middle-class will pick up the $1.5 trillion tab for the breaks afforded to corporations and the wealthy. There will be the inevitable horse-trading over the coming weeks but we can be sure of one thing: corporations will win BIG and landlords as a class will benefit too. Read More Tax-Cut Winners: Landlords! (Updated)

Tenants and Landlords: Is It Always About Class?

I’ve met many lovely people while walking my dog. There’s Ross, a newly-married young guy who, with his wife, resides in their duplex down the block. Our pups don’t really spark but Ross and I chat amiably a few mornings a week. Then there’s Dick, the retired physician who owns an immaculate fourplex around the corner. I’ve seen him on morning walks with his beagle Alice for years. This community-minded guy even picks up the litter on my block! Read More Tenants and Landlords: Is It Always About Class?